AFG Stock Analysis: American Financial | NYSE

Insurance - Property & Casualty | NYSE, USA | Market Cap: 13.264m USD | 12M Return: 21.2% | US0259321042 | Charts, Fundamentals & Technical Analysis

Property Insurance, Casualty Insurance, Specialty Financial, Surety Products
Total Rating 65
Safety 38
Buy Signal 0.92
Multi-line Insurance
Sub-Industry Rotation: +10.3
Market Cap: 13.3B
Avg Turnover: 71.9M
Risk 3d forecast
Volatility19.1%
VaR 5th Pctl3.36%
VaR vs Median6.95%
Reward TTM
Sharpe Ratio0.96
Rel. Str. IBD83.8
Rel. Str. Peer Group60.5 pctl
Character TTM
Beta0.079
Beta Downside-0.059
Hurst Exponent0.492
Choppyness38.1%
Drawdowns 3y
Max DD19.85%
CAGR/Max DD0.99
CAGR/Mean DD3.13
EPS (Earnings per Share) EPS (Earnings per Share) of AFG over the last years for every Quarter: "2021-09": 2.71, "2021-12": 4.12, "2022-03": 3.56, "2022-06": 2.85, "2022-09": 2.24, "2022-12": 2.99, "2023-03": 2.89, "2023-06": 2.38, "2023-09": 2.45, "2023-12": 2.84, "2024-03": 2.76, "2024-06": 2.56, "2024-09": 2.31, "2024-12": 3.12, "2025-03": 1.84, "2025-06": 2.14, "2025-09": 2.69, "2025-12": 3.65, "2026-03": 2.47, "2026-06": 2.82, "2026-09": 3.97,
EPS CAGR: 4.31%
EPS Trend: 45.7%
Last SUE: 2.05
Qual. Beats: 2
Revenue Revenue of AFG over the last years for every Quarter: 2021-09: 1681, 2021-12: 1437, 2022-03: 1455, 2022-06: 1463, 2022-09: 1947, 2022-12: 1908, 2023-03: 1683, 2023-06: 1812, 2023-09: 2147, 2023-12: 2086, 2024-03: 1881, 2024-06: 1886, 2024-09: 2363, 2024-12: 2148, 2025-03: 1843, 2025-06: 1930, 2025-09: 2304, 2025-12: 2041, 2026-03: 1836, 2026-06: 1992, 2026-09: 2583,
Rev. CAGR: 1.81%
Rev. Trend: 68.8%
Last SUE: 1.12
Qual. Beats: 1

Warnings

No concerns identified

Tailwinds

Seasonal Tailwind

Seasonality 11.9 years of data, until 10/2026

Jan +0.1% 0
Feb +3.2% 4
Mar -0.7% 4
Apr -0.6% 0
May -0.9% 14
Jun +1.0% 14
Jul +0.2% 14
Aug -0.4% 4
Sep -0.5% 14
Oct -0.7% 0
Nov ★ +4.7% 64
Dec -0.2% 0

How good or bad each month usually is (without trend). The score below shows how much you can trust it: 0 = pure chance, ≥40 worth a closer look and ≥60 is strong.

Description: AFG American Financial

American Financial Group, Inc. (AFG) is a Cincinnati-based insurance holding company that provides property and casualty insurance products across the United States. Founded in 1872 and listed on the NYSE since 1983, the company operates through two main segments: Property and Casualty Insurance and Other. It distributes its products primarily through independent insurance agents and brokers.

AFGs property and transportation offerings include physical damage and liability coverage for buses, trucks, specialty transportation, inland and ocean marine, agricultural-related products, and other commercial property lines. Its specialty casualty business covers excess and surplus, executive and professional liability, general liability, umbrella and excess liability, workers compensation, and tailored programs for small to mid-sized businesses.

The company also provides specialty financial insurance products such as risk management programs for lending and leasing institutions, fidelity and surety products, and trade credit insurance. Originally named American Financial Group Holdings Inc, the company adopted its current name in July 1997.

As a Multi-line Insurance provider within the Financials sector, AFG operates in a competitive industry that includes major players such as Berkshire Hathaway, The Hartford, and CNA Financial. The P&C insurance industry is heavily regulated at the state level, with pricing and underwriting practices shaped by catastrophe exposure, reinsurance costs, and reserve adequacy requirements.

Headlines to Watch Out For
  • Specialty P&C rate increases expand underwriting margins
  • Investment income benefits from elevated interest rate environment
  • Catastrophe losses pressure quarterly combined ratio results
Piotroski VR-10 (Strict) 6.5
Net Income: 1.02b TTM > 0 and > 6% of Revenue
FCF/TA: 0.05 > 0.02 and ΔFCF/TA -0.58 > 1.0
NWC/Revenue: -8.08% < 20% (prev 10.57%; Δ -18.65% < -1%)
CFO/TA 0.05 > 3% & CFO 1.75b > Net Income 1.02b
Net Debt (-12.1b) to EBITDA (1.48b): -8.21 < 3
Current Ratio: 0.97 > 1.5 & < 3
Outstanding Shares: last quarter (82.9m) vs 12m ago -0.60% < -2%
Gross Margin: 20.87% > 18% (prev 16.83%; Δ 4.04% > 0.5%)
Asset Turnover: 27.02% > 50% (prev 30.66%; Δ -3.64% > 0%)
Interest Coverage Ratio: 14.90 > 6 (EBIT TTM 1.39b / Interest Expense TTM 93.0m)
Altman Z'' 0.66
A: -0.02 (Total Current Assets 26.1b - Total Current Liabilities 26.7b) / Total Assets 35.7b
B: 0.10 (Retained Earnings 3.63b / Total Assets 35.7b)
C: 0.04 (EBIT TTM 1.39b / Avg Total Assets 31.3b)
D: 0.15 (Book Value of Equity 4.73b / Total Liabilities 31.0b)
Altman-Z'' = 0.66 = B
Beneish M -1.95
DSRI: 3.0 (Receivables 10.2b/2.03b, Revenue 8.45b/8.22b)
GMI: 0.81 (GM 16.83% / 20.87%)
AQI: 0.31 (AQ_t 0.27 / AQ_t-1 0.85)
SGI: 1.03 (Revenue 8.45b / 8.22b)
TATA: -0.02 (NI 1.02b - CFO 1.75b) / TA 35.7b)
Beneish M = -1.95 (Cap -4..+1) = B
What is the price of AFG shares?

As of November 19, 2026, the stock is trading at USD 157.95 with a total of 440,552 shares traded. Over the past week, the price has changed by +0.17%, over one month by +9.04%, over three months by +11.64% and over the past year by +21.16%.

Current recommended Stop Loss: 152.30 (which is 3.6% or 2 ATR below the current price).

Is AFG a buy, sell or hold?

American Financial has received a consensus analysts rating of 3.57. Therefore, it is recommended to hold AFG.

  • StrongBuy: 2
  • Buy: 0
  • Hold: 5
  • Sell: 0
  • StrongSell: 0

What are the forecasts/targets for the AFG price?
Analysts Target Price 158 0%
American Financial (AFG) - Fundamental Data Overview as of 14 November 2026
Market Cap USD = 13.3b (13.3b USD * 1.0 USD.USD)
P/E Trailing = 13.0726
P/E Forward = 11.534
P/S = 1.5974
P/B = 2.822
P/EG = 2.3015
Revenue TTM = 8.45b USD
EBIT TTM = 1.39b USD
EBITDA TTM = 1.48b USD
Long Term Debt = 1.82b USD (from longTermDebt, last quarter)
Short Term Debt = 39.0m USD (from shortTermDebt, last fiscal year)
Debt = 1.82b USD (from shortLongTermDebtTotal, last quarter)
Net Debt = -12.1b USD (calculated: Debt 1.82b - CCE 14.0b)
Enterprise Value = 1.13b USD (13.3b + Debt 1.82b - CCE 14.0b)
Interest Coverage Ratio = 14.90 (Ebit TTM 1.39b / Interest Expense TTM 93.0m)
EV/FCF = 0.69x (Enterprise Value 1.13b / FCF TTM 1.63b)
FCF Yield = 145.2% (FCF TTM 1.63b / Enterprise Value 1.13b)
FCF Margin = 19.33% (FCF TTM 1.63b / Revenue TTM 8.45b)
Net Margin = 12.07% (Net Income TTM 1.02b / Revenue TTM 8.45b)
Gross Margin = 20.87% ((Revenue TTM 8.45b - Cost of Revenue TTM 6.69b) / Revenue TTM)
Gross Margin QoQ = none% (prev 49.80%)
Tobins Q-Ratio = 0.03 (Enterprise Value 1.13b / Total Assets 35.7b)
Interest Expense / Debt = 5.11% (Interest Expense 93.0m / Debt 1.82b)
Taxrate = 21.11% (273.0m / 1.29b)
NOPAT = 1.09b (EBIT 1.39b * (1 - 21.11%))
Current Ratio = 0.97 (Total Current Assets 26.1b / Total Current Liabilities 26.7b)
Debt / Equity = 0.39 (Debt 1.82b / totalStockholderEquity, last quarter 4.73b)
Debt / EBITDA = -8.21 (Net Debt -12.1b / EBITDA 1.48b)
Debt / FCF = -7.43 (Net Debt -12.1b / FCF TTM 1.63b)
Total Stockholder Equity = 4.76b (last 4 quarters mean from totalStockholderEquity)
RoA = 3.26% (Net Income 1.02b / Total Assets 35.7b)
RoE = 21.42% (Net Income TTM 1.02b / Total Stockholder Equity 4.76b)
RoCE = 21.06% (EBIT 1.39b / Capital Employed (Equity 4.76b + L.T.Debt 1.82b))
RoIC = 12.70% (NOPAT 1.09b / Invested Capital 8.61b)
WACC = 5.68% (E(13.3b)/V(15.1b) * Re(5.91%) + D(1.82b)/V(15.1b) * Rd(5.11%) * (1-Tc(0.21)))
Discount Rate = 5.91% (= CAPM, Blume Beta Adj.)
Shares (quarterly) Correlation: -95.98 | Cagr: -0.53%
[DCF] Terminal Value 77.97% ; FCFF base≈1.53b ; Y1≈1.76b ; Y5≈2.59b
[DCF] Fair Price = 617.0 (EV 38.9b - Net Debt -12.1b = Equity 51.1b / Shares 82.8m; r=8.35% [WACC [floored]]; 5y FCF grow 15.0% → 2.50% )
EPS Correlation: 45.71 | EPS CAGR: 4.31% | SUE: 2.05 | # QB: 2
Revenue Correlation: 68.78 | Revenue CAGR: 1.81% | SUE: 1.12 | # QB: 1
EPS current Quarter (2027-03-31): EPS=2.79 | Chg30d=+0.78% | Revisions=+0% | Analysts=6
EPS current Year (2026-12-31): EPS=12.99 | Chg30d=+3.43% | Revisions=+50% | GrowthEPS=+26.3% | GrowthRev=+4.9%
EPS next Year (2027-12-31): EPS=12.16 | Chg30d=+0.44% | Revisions=+0% | GrowthEPS=-6.4% | GrowthRev=+4.2%
[Analyst] Revisions Ratio: +25% (up=6, down=3)