Overview Performance Dividends Peer Group Options

(SIGI) Selective Insurance - Performance -12.8% in 12m

Compare SIGI with Indices, Sectors and Commodities and Bonds. Who performs better in which timeframe?

Performance Rating 52.08%
#38 in Group
Rel. Strength 31.90%
#5435 in Universe
Total Return 12m -12.79%
#66 in Group
Total Return 5y 95.52%
#36 in Group
P/E 23.8
79th Percentile in Group
P/E Forward 11.5
33th Percentile in Group
PEG 1.86
45th Percentile in Group
FCF Yield -54.44%
76th Percentile in Group

12m Total Return: SIGI (-12.8%) vs XLF (22.7%)

Compare overall performance (total returns) of Selective Insurance with its related sector ETF XLF

5y Drawdown (Underwater) Chart

5 Year Drawdown / Underwater Chart for (SIGI) Selective Insurance - Performance -12.8% in 12m

Top Performers in Property & Casualty Insurance

Short Term
Symbol 1w 1m 3m
SIGI -4.04% -4.71% 4.16%
HRTG -0.89% 31.1% 71.7%
PRA 0.91% -0.60% 55.2%
ROOT -5.37% 4.67% 43.3%
Long Term
Symbol 6m 12m 5y
SIGI -3.14% -12.8% 95.5%
KINS 60.1% 278% 277%
HRTG 82.6% 85.1% 86.0%
ROOT 104% 101% -71.3%
Overall best picks of Peer Group Selected by proven GARP Predictive Metrics, sorted by Growth Rating
Symbol 1m 12m 5y P/E P/E Forward PEG EPS
Stability		 EPS
CAGR
FFH TO
Fairfax Financial Holdings		 3.48% 45.4% 564% 9.54 10.3 0.28 30.5% -0.15%
IFC TO
Intact Financial		 4.14% 38% 157% 23.8 17.9 0.87 -17.4% -28.1%
KNSL NYSE
Kinsale Capital		 -10.6% 20% 277% 24.2 23.4 1.56 87.7% 18.8%
ALL NYSE
The Allstate		 -4.19% 19% 124% 11.5 11 1.97 42.0% 48.3%
HCI NYSE
HCI		 -1.96% 30.1% 296% 16.2 8.75 1.7 61.8% 26.2%
AIZ NYSE
Assurant		 -8.11% 12.2% 111% 12.7 11.8 1.46 35.8% -32%
SKWD NASDAQ
Skyward Specialty Insurance		 0.32% 52% 254% 18.1 15.3 0.72 73.7% 3.53%
SIGI NASDAQ
Selective Insurance		 -4.71% -12.8% 95.5% 23.8 11.5 1.86 32.7% 2.22%

Performance Comparison: SIGI vs XLF vs S&P 500

XLF (Financial Sector SPDR Fund ETF) is the Sector Benchmark for SIGI
Total Return (including Dividends) SIGI XLF S&P 500
1 Month -4.71% -2.11% -0.87%
3 Months 4.16% -4.92% -7.58%
12 Months -12.79% 22.69% 11.88%
5 Years 95.52% 144.89% 110.33%
Trend Score (consistency of price movement) SIGI XLF S&P 500
1 Month 1.30% 27.8% 23%
3 Months 68.4% -81% -88.5%
12 Months -33.5% 83.7% 55.1%
5 Years 83.0% 75.1% 84.1%
Relative Strength (compared with Indexes) Rank in Peer Group vs. XLF vs. S&P 500
1 Month #48 -2.66% -3.87%
3 Month #35 9.55% 12.7%
12 Month #65 -28.9% -22.1%
5 Years #39 -20.2% -7.04%

FAQs

Does SIGI Selective Insurance outperforms the market?

No, over the last 12 months SIGI made -12.79%, while its related Sector, the Financial Sector SPDR Fund (XLF) made 22.69%.
Over the last 3 months SIGI made 4.16%, while XLF made -4.92%.

Performance Comparison SIGI vs Indeces and Sectors

SIGI vs. Indices SIGI is Over or Underperforming

Symbol 1w 1m 6m 12m
US S&P 500 SPY -7.61% -3.84% -1.28% -24.7%
US NASDAQ 100 QQQ -8.64% -6.11% -1.71% -25.5%
US Dow Jones Industrial 30 DIA -6.67% -1.53% -1.19% -22.0%
German DAX 40 DAX -6.38% -6.03% -20.8% -37.5%
Shanghai Shenzhen CSI 300 CSI 300 -3.65% -1.89% 1.71% -18.8%
Hongkong Hang Seng HSI -6.62% -4.77% -3.20% -26.7%
India NIFTY 50 INDA -4.77% -8.77% -1.57% -15.9%
Brasil Bovespa EWZ -6.81% -9.31% -4.98% -6.97%

SIGI vs. Sectors SIGI is Over or Underperforming

Symbol 1w 1m 6m 12m
Communication Services XLC -7.86% -3.66% -7.41% -36.8%
Consumer Discretionary XLY -7.69% -4.61% -3.79% -26.1%
Consumer Staples XLP -4.11% -4.91% -6.59% -24.0%
Energy XLE -3.13% 9.15% 4.51% -1.70%
Financial XLF -6.22% -2.60% -8.88% -35.5%
Health Care XLV -7.53% -0.92% 0.41% -14.5%
Industrial XLI -8.03% -4.82% -1.99% -22.4%
Materials XLB -7.0% -2.28% 6.13% -9.27%
Real Estate XLRE -6.09% -3.40% -0.39% -30.9%
Technology XLK -10.1% -6.40% 2.06% -20.5%
Utilities XLU -4.77% -4.77% -3.40% -34.6%
Aerospace & Defense XAR -8.56% -11.1% -14.8% -39.4%
Biotech XBI -8.91% -6.99% 11.4% -11.0%
Homebuilder XHB -6.92% -2.44% 13.5% -5.76%
Retail XRT -6.04% -4.15% 4.29% -10.1%

SIGI vs. Commodities SIGI is Over or Underperforming

Symbol 1w 1m 6m 12m
Oil USO 2.56% 13.1% 9.89% 6.12%
Natural Gas UNG -10.5% 17.8% -34.9% -28.7%
Gold GLD -4.08% -10.1% -23.0% -56.2%
Silver SLV -0.90% -0.22% -2.44% -35.9%
Copper CPER 1.99% 4.97% -7.45% -13.6%

SIGI vs. Yields & Bonds SIGI is Over or Underperforming

Symbol 1w 1m 6m 12m
iShares 20+ Years Bond TLT -6.50% -3.35% -1.97% -18.4%
iShares High Yield Corp. Bond HYG -4.81% -4.83% -5.36% -22.1%